Showing posts with label Mahie Gill. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mahie Gill. Show all posts

Sunday, September 8, 2013

Carnival of 'Rust'

Film: Zanjeer

Director: Apoorva Lakhia


Prakash Mehra's Zanjeer (which was made in a much simpler time when it was acceptable to see an angry young man take on an army of goons), charted a path for Amitabh as the angry young man, gave Pran yet another unforgettable role as Sher Khan and was laden with heavy duty dialogues and story of the hit duo Salim-Javed. Apoorva Lakhia's re-make, starring Ram Charan, is simply a loud, confused tale, oscillating between the genre of the angry young man and the new-age Dabangg sensibility.


The adapted screenplay, written by Suresh Nair and the director himself, doesn't deviate much from the plot structure of the original, save for setting the film in contemporary times (something that the re-hashers of Agneepath did not do). The protagonist, Vijay Khanna, who is tormented by the same dream of a masked murderer on a horse, kicks the chair and says “yeh police station hai, tumhare baap ka ghar nahi. Jab tak baithne ke liye kaha na jaye, chup chap khade raho” and has the swagger of a young man whose blood is boiling. However, this, and many more parallels that are subconsciously made by everyone who has seen the original, make Lakhia's film look like a cheap imitation.

Prakash Raj, who re-creates Ajit's character on screen, is reduced to a comic relief element for almost the entire first half. His opening scene, which shows him slit a man's throat after a house-servant whispers “Sir, gaddaar Shaun hai” in his ears, makes him appear more amusing than intimidating. Majority of his scenes are laden with unnecessary sexual overtones and see him reduced to a joke. Similarly, Mahie Gill, who plays Mona, is a colossal waste of a talented actor, as she moans and grunts her way through dialogues that add absolutely no substance to the film.

The only plus point of the film is Ram Charan's physique, which for the first time, allows the angry young man to take off his shirt and not look like a malnourished child from Sudan (apologies to AB of 40 years ago). Priyanka Chopra too is reduced to a good looking girl, who is just a narrative tool for a few moments of romance and intimacy.

The lesser said about Sanjay Dutt's Sher Khan, the better. Comparison with Pran is a sin we aren't willing to commit. But getting to re-live those lines itself would have been a good experience, had Dutt not spoiled it with his monotony.

Having made this film when police officer protagonists are selling like hot cakes, Zanjeer struggles to find its identity as whether it wanted to be a re-creation of the seventies' sentiment or a remix, which incorporated the story in today's age of Singham and Chulbul Pandey.

The film doesn't actively bore you, but leaves you with nothing to cherish. And if by the end of the first half, you're still not sure if this is a remake, Mahie Gill says to Prakash Raj, while watching Ajit and Bindu in the original Zanjeer, “Tumhari personality kitni milti julti hai.” Well, you decide.

Rating: 1 out of 5

Published in DNA (Pune) on September 7, 2013

Monday, March 11, 2013

This Time It's Personal




Between Saheb Biwi Aur Gangster and its sequel that released yesterday, a lot has changed for Tigmanshu Dhulia. First and foremost, he has become a known face, thanks to his negative role in last year's Anurag Kashyap epic Gangs of Wasseypur as Ramadhir Singh. And how could anybody forget Ramadhir's comment, "Jab tak iss desh mein saneema hai, public c****ya banti rahegi." On that background, Saheb Biwi Aur Gangster Returns is a treat for all the cine-phile c****yas.

Set on the backdrop of the division of Uttar Pradesh, the film uses the political scenario as a subplot to engage you in a war that is very personal. Picking up from where he left in the first film, Tigmanshu begins the sequel with wheelchairridden Saheb; who intends to marry Ranjana (Soha Ali Khan), a Rajput heiress, for progeny. Ranjana however, is in love with gangster Indrajeet Singh; whose aim is to avenge his family's lost heritage by killing Saheb. On the other side is the biwi, Madhavi Devi (Mahie Gill), a puppet MLA, trying hard to play the game by her own rules. By now, you find yourself in a web of interpersonal conflicts and as the film progresses, you only go deeper into this web, which then consumes you.

Unlike the first part, this film has no shortage of great performances. Irrfan Khan, who has worked with Tigmanshu in Paan Singh Tomar, continues charming audiences with his act as a Rajput. Jimmy Sheirgill puts in a brilliant performance and outlines the journey of Saheb as he reemerges to power with the right amount of conceit and flamboyance. Mahie Gill fits the bill as the neglected, disrespected wife; but it is sad to see her getting typecast in such roles. Soha Ali Khan pitches in with what is perhaps her best work on the screen and Pravesh, who makes his debut, is a little stagnant but bearable.

The film is composed brilliantly with specific motifs for every character and scores full marks on its microstructure. Unfortunately, what the film lacks is the same elements that were missing in the previous film too. The music is just not up to the mark. An unnecessary item number by Mugdha Godse does nothing but add to the duration of the film and another song in the film simply reminds you of Aarambh from Gulaal. If you cover your ears a little and ignore the lyrics, you will find the similarities.

The second shortcoming is the production value of the film. In some places, the costumes just don't look royal enough and create a paradox. However, made on a comparatively low budget, the film does convey a lot through its sets, which stand for the fallen prestige of India's royal families.

Through Saheb Biwi Aur Gangster Returns, Tigmanshu Dhulia brings you a thriller, political drama with a grownup romance and a tale of heartbreak at the bottom of it. The film makes you identify with the characters, take sides and as it progresses, introduces a predicament which may make you want to change sides. Engaging to say the least, this will go down as one of this year's better Hindi films.


Rating - 3.5 out of 5


Published in DNA After Hrs (Pune) on March 9, 2013